What To Know
- Both the Vivosmart HR and the Scanwatch 42mm excel in fitness tracking, offering a wide range of features to monitor your activity levels.
- The Vivosmart HR provides real-time heart rate data on the display, while the Scanwatch 42mm displays it in the accompanying app.
- The Scanwatch 42mm also offers a variety of other health monitoring features, such as a body temperature sensor, a heart rate variability monitor, and a stress tracker.
Choosing the right fitness tracker can be a daunting task, especially when faced with a plethora of options. Two popular contenders often make the shortlist: the Garmin Vivosmart HR and the Withings Scanwatch 42mm. Both devices offer a compelling blend of fitness tracking, health monitoring, and stylish design, but they cater to different needs and preferences. In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll delve deep into the features, pros, and cons of each device to help you make an informed decision.
Design and Comfort: A Tale of Two Styles
The Garmin Vivosmart HR and the Withings Scanwatch 42mm couldn’t be more different in terms of design. The Vivosmart HR opts for a sleek and minimalist approach with a thin, rubbery band and a small, monochrome OLED display. This design is ideal for discreet wear, blending seamlessly with any outfit.
On the other hand, the Scanwatch 42mm embraces a more traditional watch aesthetic. It boasts a circular stainless steel case with a sapphire glass display and a selection of interchangeable straps. This design exudes elegance and sophistication, making it a stylish accessory for everyday wear.
In terms of comfort, the Vivosmart HR’s lightweight design and flexible band provide a comfortable fit for extended wear. The Scanwatch 42mm, while heavier, still offers a comfortable fit thanks to its well-designed strap system. However, some users might find its larger size slightly bulky, especially for smaller wrists.
Fitness Tracking: A Comprehensive Comparison
Both the Vivosmart HR and the Scanwatch 42mm excel in fitness tracking, offering a wide range of features to monitor your activity levels. Let’s break down their capabilities:
Activity Tracking: Both devices accurately track steps, distance, calories burned, and active minutes. The Vivosmart HR also provides detailed insights into your sleep patterns, including sleep stages and sleep quality. The Scanwatch 42mm goes a step further by offering automatic sleep detection and sleep apnea detection.
Heart Rate Monitoring: Both devices feature continuous heart rate monitoring, allowing you to track your heart rate throughout the day and during workouts. The Vivosmart HR provides real-time heart rate data on the display, while the Scanwatch 42mm displays it in the accompanying app.
GPS Tracking: The Vivosmart HR doesn‘t include built-in GPS, so you’ll need to rely on your smartphone’s GPS for accurate location tracking during outdoor workouts. The Scanwatch 42mm, on the other hand, boasts built-in GPS, enabling you to track your runs, walks, and bike rides without needing your phone.
Workout Tracking: Both devices offer a variety of workout modes, including running, walking, cycling, swimming, and more. The Vivosmart HR provides basic workout metrics, while the Scanwatch 42mm offers more detailed insights like pace, cadence, and elevation.
Other Features: The Vivosmart HR includes features like move reminders, stress tracking, and smart notifications. The Scanwatch 42mm adds SpO2 monitoring, which measures blood oxygen levels, and ECG functionality, which allows you to take an electrocardiogram to detect potential heart problems.
Health Monitoring: Beyond Fitness Tracking
While both devices excel in fitness tracking, the Scanwatch 42mm truly shines in health monitoring. Its advanced features set it apart from the Vivosmart HR, making it a more comprehensive health companion.
ECG and SpO2 Monitoring: The Scanwatch 42mm’s built-in ECG and SpO2 sensors provide valuable insights into your cardiovascular health. The ECG functionality allows you to take an electrocardiogram to detect potential heart problems, while the SpO2 sensor measures your blood oxygen levels, which can be helpful for monitoring sleep quality and detecting potential health issues.
Sleep Apnea Detection: The Scanwatch 42mm’s sleep apnea detection feature is a game-changer for individuals concerned about this condition. It analyzes your breathing patterns during sleep and can identify potential sleep apnea episodes.
Blood Oxygen Monitoring: The Scanwatch 42mm also provides continuous blood oxygen monitoring, allowing you to track your oxygen levels throughout the day and night. This feature can be particularly useful for individuals with respiratory conditions or those living at high altitudes.
Other Features: The Scanwatch 42mm also offers a variety of other health monitoring features, such as a body temperature sensor, a heart rate variability monitor, and a stress tracker.
Battery Life: Endurance and Convenience
Battery life is a crucial factor for any fitness tracker, and both the Vivosmart HR and the Scanwatch 42mm offer respectable performance. The Vivosmart HR boasts a battery life of up to 7 days, while the Scanwatch 42mm delivers up to 30 days of battery life in standard mode and up to 8 days with GPS and heart rate monitoring enabled.
The Vivosmart HR‘s shorter battery life might require more frequent charging, but it’s still manageable. The Scanwatch 42mm’s extended battery life offers greater convenience, allowing you to go for longer periods without needing to recharge.
Price and Value: Finding the Right Balance
The Garmin Vivosmart HR and the Withings Scanwatch 42mm fall into different price categories. The Vivosmart HR is typically more affordable, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious consumers. The Scanwatch 42mm, with its advanced health monitoring features and premium design, comes at a higher price point.
Ultimately, the best value depends on your individual needs and priorities. If you’re primarily looking for a basic fitness tracker with solid activity tracking and heart rate monitoring, the Vivosmart HR offers excellent value for the price. However, if you prioritize advanced health monitoring features and a stylish design, the Scanwatch 42mm is a worthwhile investment.
The Verdict: Choosing the Right Tracker for You
So, which fitness tracker reigns supreme? The answer depends on your individual needs and preferences.
Choose the Garmin Vivosmart HR if:
- You prioritize affordability and a minimalist design.
- You’re looking for a basic fitness tracker with solid activity tracking and heart rate monitoring.
- You’re comfortable relying on your smartphone’s GPS for location tracking.
Choose the Withings Scanwatch 42mm if:
- You prioritize advanced health monitoring features, including ECG, SpO2, and sleep apnea detection.
- You value a stylish and sophisticated design.
- You want a long battery life that can last for weeks.
Beyond the Comparison: A Final Thought
Both the Garmin Vivosmart HR and the Withings Scanwatch 42mm are excellent fitness trackers that offer a range of features to enhance your health and fitness journey. Ultimately, the best choice for you depends on your individual needs and priorities. Consider your budget, desired features, and personal style to make an informed decision.
Basics You Wanted To Know
Q: Which device is better for athletes?
A: Both devices are suitable for athletes, but the Scanwatch 42mm edges out the Vivosmart HR with its built-in GPS and more detailed workout tracking metrics.
Q: Which device is better for sleep tracking?
A: The Scanwatch 42mm offers more advanced sleep tracking features, including automatic sleep detection, sleep apnea detection, and blood oxygen monitoring during sleep.
Q: Which device is more comfortable to wear?
A: The Vivosmart HR’s lightweight design and flexible band make it more comfortable for extended wear, especially for those with smaller wrists.
Q: Which device is more stylish?
A: The Scanwatch 42mm’s traditional watch design and interchangeable straps make it a more stylish option for everyday wear.
Q: Which device is better overall?
A: The best device for you depends on your individual needs and priorities. If you prioritize advanced health monitoring features, the Scanwatch 42mm is the clear winner. However, if you’re looking for a more affordable and comfortable fitness tracker, the Vivosmart HR is a solid choice.